Uncanny Alpha Flight, Good idea or not?

[Puck]

:)

[beetleblack]

I voted YES, but I'm certainly not holding my breathe. I just think it would be cool to see more of the original team back together again.

[Mystic]

I would definitely be interested in another ALpha Flight series, but only if it involved the classic AF. If it was another team of newbies, I wouldn't.

-Mystic

[Ben]

The whole concept behind "Uncanny AF" is that it would consist of the origonal team, or very close to it.


I would definitely be interested in another ALpha Flight series, but only if it involved the classic AF. If it was another team of newbies, I wouldn't.

-Mystic

[Phil]

I don't like to say it but I really doubt that there's a big enough fan base of the old team to justify two titles.
I fear for Volume 3 as it is...

[HavokThePowerful]

I voted no I think vol. 3 is good enough don't want it to start spanning mutiple titles (cough:X-men)

[kozzi24]

There should have been a vote option of yes, REPLACE the current trash book with a classic Alpha Flight. As Marvel I think will soon learn with FF and Captain America, the market doesn't seem able to support more than one Alpha Book.

[DelBubs]

There should have been a vote option of yes, REPLACE the current trash book with a classic Alpha Flight. As Marvel I think will soon learn with FF and Captain America, the market doesn't seem able to support more than one Alpha Book.

The only way a second AF book would really work, if is Wolvie joined up for 10/11 issues :-) Alpha are just far enough away from the main MU to negate a second book without real pulling power like Wolvie.

I'm, prepared to see where Lobdell is going after the first arc, before I commit to how much I like/dislike the book. At present it's good to see AF in print again and he hasn't done enough to send me running for the hills yet. :?:

[beetleblack]

However would Wolverine find the time to be in yet another comic title??? :lol: He's alread in every X-titled book plus his own title!!! Thing is I have no idea how he got so popular!!!

[DelBubs]

Oh don't get me wrong, Wolverine is well overused in the MU, but unfortunately teams based outside the US just don't draw the interest. Excalibur probably wouldn't have worked if it hadn't been full of former X-Men, Clandestine went tits up after 12 issues. Alpha needs a bigger tie to the MU than it has at present, Wolvie has ties to AF so wouldn't be out of place if he went back for a short while. Otherwise ... :?:

[beetleblack]

True enough, I just think it's a shame the character is now so overused that it's hard to figure out when certain stories took place in context to others etc (if that makes any sense).

I think it would be interesting to see Wolverine on the team, if only for the tension between him Mac and Heather. (Btw, how many men can one woman enamour - maybe Heather Hudson is a mutant, which the ability to enamour men to her? Enamour might actually be a good name if they decided to go that way... okay, going way OT here :lol: )

[kozzi24]

Btw, how many men can one woman enamour -
Redheads have that ability, but there is a downside of men repulsed by them. If they showed that just once, maybe it would negate this seeming ability she has.

[HappyCanuck]

The only way a second AF book would really work, if is Wolvie joined up for 10/11 issues :-) Alpha are just far enough away from the main MU to negate a second book without real pulling power like Wolvie.



That brings up a good question: using existing Marvel characters - who have NOT been a part of AF before, either in print or implied (ie: Wolverine would be considered and 'implied' character as long as you ignore the 'First Flight' story) - who would YOU add to the Flight (thinking especially to make the title more marketable). And no, the character does not necessarily have to be Canadian (but imho, they would have to be Canuck to lead... but now I'm babbling)

[kozzi24]

There is one long standing character with natural ties to the book: Namor.
Part of the reason a heberal Alpha Flight title may be hard for new readers is that it already has so many characyers associated with the book. I don't think anyone should be added, but reader interest could be provoked if the team fights popular villains: Magneto, Skrulls, Doom, other X-foes.
As a f'instance, a battle with the Juggernaut in an AF style could be at least two unpadded issues of sheer actionL Sasquatch vs Jugs in the first, the entire team in the second.

[HappyCanuck]

As a f'instance, a battle with the Juggernaut in an AF style could be at least two unpadded issues of sheer actionL Sasquatch vs Jugs in the first, the entire team in the second.

This time, tho, without the damned battle armour :D

[suzene]

I vote no...I love the old team, but they've drifted so far apart, I'd just as soon let the past lie.

Suzene

[Ottawa Renegade]

I vote no...I love the old team, but they've drifted so far apart, I'd just as soon let the past lie.

Suzene

If they did it then, I'd want them to do it kind of like they did issues 5-10 or so of Version 1. START with the characters apart and unite them gradually.

I think it might even be interesting to have something of a rivalry between the two teams. If Alphas both old and new got back together, I could see either Mac or Heather naturally gravitating towards taking a leadership role. It might be kind of neat to see the newbies say "Sorry, Walt is our boss" and only want to work together under him.

[Major Mapleleaf Jr]

I voted no. Mac and Heather need to retire, raise their daughter, and get their s*** together. Shaman just needs to retire, period, like he's been apparently trying to do. Snowbird needs to go find something to do. Puck should definitely walk away from Alpha Flight for a while, because it caused him a LOT of grief in v2. Maybe he and Walt can go out for a drink and let the rookies run things for a while (when they're ready). Not that I dislike any of them... I LOVE Alpha Flight, and I would read an Uncanny Alpha Flight religiously. But I don't think it's the right time for such a series.

[SwiftFox]

Why stop there??? How about....

Fantastic Flight
The Amazing Shaman-man
The Incredible Sasquatch
The Invincible Box
????

[Airhead]

I voted Yes!
I think it would be a great idea!
(plus the team won't be as crowded with two books!)

[Richv1]

I think it would be a great idea since Canada does have more than enough super-heroes to support two teams.