• Amazing X-Men #9 Review

    WARNING: This Review contains MAJOR SPOILERS for the issue.

    Amazing X-Men #9

    Writers:
    Craig Kyle & Chris Yost
    Penciler: Carlo Barberi
    Inkers: Walden Wong, David Meikis, Carlo Barberi
    Colorist: Rachelle Rosenberg
    Letterer: Joe Caramagna
    Cover: Ed McGuinness & Marte Garcia
    Cover Date: September 2014

    World War Wendigo! Part 2 of 5

    The Wendigo outbreak we saw at the end of last issue really ramps up from the very start of the issue and is told out of sequence in a very horror film-esque way, which essentially is what this arc is playing on.

    Artist Carlo Barberi, with Walden Wong & David Meikis, captures these scenes really well, in a very 'widescreen' film way, showing the isolation and desolation of the towns.
    There are a lot of scenes very similar to contagion films such as Outbreak, 28 Days Later and well, World War Z that go on to show how serious this all is; the police force and the Avengers are shown as unable to cope with the forces of the Wendigo as Canada starts to fall.
    This is a Canadian problem and it's up to Canadians to solve it. Oh, and the X-Men who are inadvertedly trapped in Canada after rushing to Wolverine's aid. But hey; it's their book and that's understandable.

    Craig Kyle & Chris Yost have woven a very solid tale here, that has echoes of the films/genre mentioned above and I was nostalgically reminded of the classic X-Men Brood saga, which also played off horror and sci-fi themes. I like the fact that the Wendigo are a deadly threat.

    The team dynamic works really well here and gives off that 'old-school' Claremont vibe. Maybe it's simply Nightcrawler's return, but this book definitely feels like the X-family should; Kurt and Piotr work so well together, Ororo is a firm but caring leader, and Iceman provides his pivotal role of comic relief.

    But enough about the X-Men.
    Well, to a degree anyway; we've got an inside man now!

    Northstar isn't given a great deal of panel-time/lines, though that's due to the size of the cast and he gets equally as much as the others, but what he does get is classic Jean-Paul snark and sarcasm.
    The notion of him flying within the Blackbird, whilst flying, was a really nice touch (although he's happily sat in the plane before many times) and to me show that Kyle & Yost actually get the character. Which I'm grateful for.


    While we don't get to see the fate of Guardian & Vindicator we do get Talisman and Puck stepping in to save Wolverine's (Canadian) bacon, presumably following on from Heather's voicemail in the previous issue, or maybe just because Liz could sense what was going on. Or maybe they just had access to a TV with the news on, who knows?

    I'd like to think that they alerted the rest of the team and that they're on their way to help. Hopefully we'll get to see some more Alphans next issue, but given the size of the cast already I can understand keeping the guest stars to a minimum.

    Talisman is shown in her Omega Flight-era costume which fits with when we last saw her (with speaking lines anyway, ignoring her cameo in Uncanny Avengers) and Puck is back in his uniform, which... I'm actually sort of saddened by.
    I'd gotten quite used to seeing Puck in street clothes over in Uncanny X-Force, especially not having a headcap. Alpha's uniforms don't match each other anyway (apart from the 90's, obviously) so Puck having an X-jacket wouldn't really be too out of place, but I suppose a classic is a classic for a reason!

    Talisman is shown as a serious contender in the magical world (which makes it strange that her father's not mentioned at all) with a nice nod to her She-Hulk guest appearance, as the last time she fought Wendigo and it's good to see an Alphan being shown as powerful and with respect, as opposed to Dr Strange showing up and waving his magic fingers all the time.

    However, that respect leads me to the last page...

    The solicitation for #10 includes the line: "As the Wendigo virus runs rampant through Canada, one of the X-Men falls prey to the deadly plague!"
    We get to see the start of that here as Wolverine becomes a Wendigo (Wendirine? Wolvigo?) and snikt's Talisman right through the chest before she's able to complete a curing spell.


    I had surmised (and feared) after reading #8 that the Puck/Talisman relationship (or hook-up) seemed a bit forced and that it was there just as a fodder to future drama and I really fear that that was because Liz is going the way of Diamond Lil.

    This does nothing to help alleviate that fear I'm afraid.

    However, we all know about comics' revolving death policy, especially where magic is concerned.
    The solicitation for #11 supports this "the X-Men take the battle to a new front—the Spirit Realm!" which makes me think we'll get a deus ex machina that'll bring Liz back to life.

    As mentioned above, the artwork for this issue comes from Carlo Barberi who provides a very seamless transition from Ed McGuinness' work in the last issue; a very classic superhero look - not too cartoony, not too gritty. The action scenes are very dynamic and the Wendigo look bloodthirsty and a definite viable threat. There's also a very nice panel featuring Nightcrawler reflected in Colossus' head which I really appreciated for some reason.
    There seemed something slightly off with the angle of Puck's head on the splash-page he first appears on, but his other appearances don't suffer from the same thing.

    Colours for the issue are once again provided by Rachelle Rosenberg who makes Talisman's magic stand out well, especially in that last page, using a blue hue to stand out from earlier pages focusing on the bloodthirsty Wendigo where a lot of red was used and the pages showcasing the Blackbird exploding where orange filled panel borders to great effect.


    As I mentioned earlier there's nothing within the issue regarding Heather & Mac, however the fact that Wolverine has become a Wendigo implies that there'll be an easy fix because we all know he's not staying as one, so there's a good chance we'll see them both back. (And maybe then we'll get a reunion with Claire.)

    Although if the two of them survive that makes me think Talisman is less likely to...
    There has to be some kind of gravitas and loss from this outbreak.
    Having it all just go back to exactly the way it was would take away the impact from what is a very decent written X-Men story thus-far.
    Comments 32 Comments
    1. TSOG's Avatar
      TSOG -
      We do see a Wendigo with a streak of red "fur" and green shorts. So I suspect that's our "hint" that Heather is turned.
    1. Phil's Avatar
      Phil -
      I'm glad you picked up on that too; I wasn't sure if I was just seeing what I wanted to see.
    1. TSOG's Avatar
      TSOG -
      I didn't really pick up on anything relative to Mac though, but I read it quickly.

      Frankly, I couldn't finish it fast enough especially when it became clear that Alpha's contribution was going to be pretty light. Man, I'm surprised at how irritating Iceman is now. He didn't seem that bad during the few issues of Uncanny (?) I bought leading up to Northstar's wedding. At least he's still his usual charming self.
    1. -K-M-'s Avatar
      -K-M- -
      Good review

      Glad you guys said that, because I'm partially color blind and never even noticed the red haha. I called it she would be turned so not surprised.

      Wonder why bites and scratches are enough to turn people? Seems Talisman could be turned now too
    1. Alphan East's Avatar
      Alphan East -
      Great review. I am really enjoying this story arc... or at least I was until the last page. Its hard to tell with Marvel, sometimes death is death and sometimes its a 3 month absence.
      I think the Wendigo with the red tint in it's mane was a stroke of genius... very subtle, yet most people realised it right away. Brilliant.
      The mention of the Spirit Realm in issue 11 gives me hope that Talisman will return.
      One thing though, and please enlighten me if I'm wrong. I've read most of the Wendigo appearances over the years and always believed that there were two ways (and two ways only) to become a Wendigo. A) eating human flesh in Canada, and B) being turned by magic. I don't remember "bites and scratches" being used before.
    1. -K-M-'s Avatar
      -K-M- -
      Bites turned people during the story in Hulk where a Wendigo clan went to Las Vegas. Can't remember if scratches did too.

      Other then that Wendigo didn't create more Wendigo generally one at a time (except Chaos War: Alpha Flight and the Hulk issue).
    1. Flightpath07's Avatar
      Flightpath07 -
      Quote Originally Posted by -K-M- View Post
      Bites turned people during the story in Hulk where a Wendigo clan went to Las Vegas. Can't remember if scratches did too.

      Other then that Wendigo didn't create more Wendigo generally one at a time (except Chaos War: Alpha Flight and the Hulk issue).
      So...unless somebody comes up with a "why" that explains the curse now being transmitted in different ways...shouldn't we just say that this is writers/editors not doing proper research? And by that, i mean not just Kyle and Yost, but those who came before as well.
    1. Phil's Avatar
      Phil -
      I'm pretty sure that why will be a part of the plot as it's been mentioned a few times in the issue.
    1. Flightpath07's Avatar
      Flightpath07 -
      Quote Originally Posted by Phil View Post
      I'm pretty sure that why will be a part of the plot as it's been mentioned a few times in the issue.
      Always the optimist, eh?
    1. TSOG's Avatar
      TSOG -
      "Talisman is shown as a serious contender in the magical world (which makes it strange that her father's not mentioned at all) with a nice nod to her She-Hulk guest appearance,..."

      See how easy it can be?
    1. Phil's Avatar
      Phil -
      To put in a non-specific nod to something that actually happened on a printed page, yes.

      To fill in something that happened off panel, or specifically mention something, no.
    1. TSOG's Avatar
      TSOG -
      Lol...All right, have it your way. don't worry, you won't have to hear about it again.
    1. Phil's Avatar
      Phil -
      Naaaaaah, don't stop on my behalf.

      I'd rather sit here and debate opposing points of view on Alpha related stuff with you folks than do most other things.
    1. Flightpath07's Avatar
      Flightpath07 -
      Quote Originally Posted by Phil View Post
      Naaaaaah, don't stop on my behalf.

      I'd rather sit here and debate opposing points of view on Alpha related stuff with you folks than do most other things.
      No you wouldn't.
    1. Le Messor's Avatar
      Le Messor -
      Quote Originally Posted by Alphan East View Post
      I think the Wendigo with the red tint in it's mane was a stroke of genius... very subtle, yet most people realised it right away. Brilliant.
      I noticed that, but I just figured it'd turned some random person with a dyed streak in their hair. Because otherwise it makes no sense - nobody else has retained any part of their natural colour, why should this person? (Heather, for example.)

      Quote Originally Posted by Alphan East View Post
      I've read most of the Wendigo appearances over the years and always believed that there were two ways (and two ways only) to become a Wendigo. A) eating human flesh in Canada, and B) being turned by magic. I don't remember "bites and scratches" being used before.
      Quote Originally Posted by Flightpath07 View Post
      shouldn't we just say that this is writers/editors not doing proper research?
      Quote Originally Posted by Phil View Post
      I'm pretty sure that why will be a part of the plot as it's been mentioned a few times in the issue.
      Given that it WAS mentioned as something new, something different, I don't think it can be put down to poor research. The writers obviously know this isn't how it used to be.

      These Wendigis are more like werewolves right now. (This isn't a complaint, just an observation.)

      Quote Originally Posted by Flightpath07 View Post
      No you wouldn't.
      That isn't an argument! It's just contradiction!
    1. Flightpath07's Avatar
      Flightpath07 -
      Quote Originally Posted by Le Messor View Post
      That isn't an argument! It's just contradiction!
      Oh yeah?! Prove it!
    1. Le Messor's Avatar
      Le Messor -
      Look, an argument is an interconnected series of statements designed to to arrive at a conclusion. It's not just the automatic gainsaying of what the other person says.
    1. Flightpath07's Avatar
      Flightpath07 -
      I disagree with your attempts to control my thoughts. Putting on my tinfoil hat now. There, I said it; HAT. I win.
    1. Le Messor's Avatar
      Le Messor -
      'Hat'?

      My argument is invalid.
    1. Mokole's Avatar
      Mokole -
      But why stab Talisman? Why not stab an X-Man for a change? If you're going to sell a story stab someone who Wolverinedigo would want to stab, and have repercussions.