Yeah, so if she weren't killed, it wouldn't make sense for Magik to say that she found Witchfire reincarnted. The rest of the statment was,
Code:
What she’s referring to by “reincarnated” is difficult to understand, unless it means “reconstituted” as opposed to “resurrected.” At the ending of X-Infernus, Witchfire is shown escaping Limbo, seemingly alive, so the notion of being “reconstituted” would make much more sense.
By the way, you can make comments on my other site for specific posts, which might be preferable for narrow topics such as this, whatever!
Love,
rplass